Saturday, March 27, 2010

Snake Oil Sellers Alive and Well

When I was young I lived in a very small town in Tennessee. We were right on the NC&StL railroad with a depot. As a small boy I would walk down the 200 yards to the depot to see the people getting off the train.


Most were just people coming home from shopping trips or coming to town for business, we had a hosiery mill, milk processing plant and The Webb School. I am talking about late 30s to early 40s.


Occasionally there would be a well dressed, smooth talking, well educated, "Snake Oil" salesman who came to town. This person had all the answers to what ails people. Usually there would be a tent erected for the presentation so everyone in town could hear the spiel. It all sounded so great and the people would put up their hard earned money to purchase this wonderfully touted elixir which was supposed do magical things. When the show was over and everyone had rushed to get a supply of the magic elixir, the 'Snake Oil" man would catch the last train out of town.


The next morning people would awaken and realize that it had been just another "Snake Oil" salesman that worked his magic on small towns. Too late, he was gone with most of the money that the people who expected something for nothing had spent.


It is 2010 and I sense "Snake Oil" attempting to be sold in my home town. An expert has been brought in with all the magic words, and he is saying exactly what many of the people want to hear regarding our problems with "Illegal Immigration". Guess what, he is well dressed, smooth talking, well educated, a stranger with a brief case, an expert in what he sells, .......


Dealing with people problems in organizations and taking part in two wars, I have learned that there is no Magical Elixir to cure for organizational, municipal or "Illegal Immigration" problems.


Why does the "Snake Oil" person come to the small towns? I don't have all the answers, but it is my guess that larger towns usually have the expert power needed and a much stronger infrastructure. The small town usually has very few people who actually make the decisions and he has only that small group to sell. This small group is our elected officials.


The longer the "illegal immigration" problem has been allowed to exist the more embedded it is in the actual culture of a small town. Example, when I drive down the main street of my home town, the majority of the businesses are Hispanic, in a town that in the mid 8Os had very few if any people of Hispanic descent.


We are a town strapped for tax dollars. A new store recently opened called "Dirt Cheap". On every shelf I noticed signs "No Exchange, No Refunds. This is exactly how I feel about hiring this out-of-town expert. I think we will wind up with something we really don't like and stuck with "No exchange, No Refund".


Buyer beware.

1 comment:

  1. I am glad you are blogging again. In banking I saw quite a few snake oil guys and you can spot them a mile away. I adopted the motto: Assume everything out of their mouth is a lie.
    That generally worked out to be the case. If it looks to good to be true, it probably is.
    Love,
    Karen

    ReplyDelete